Utopia Bagels

Verified
4.6 (10) Rate your experience!
  • Bagel shop
  • 120 E 34th St, New York, NY 10016
  • Today Hours : 6AM-4PM
Utopia Bagels

About Utopia Bagels

Service options
Delivery Onsite services Takeout Dine-in
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance No Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
Coffee
Dining options
Breakfast
Amenities
Restroom
Planning
Quick visit
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments
Parking
Free street parking

Opening Hours

Reviews on Utopia Bagels

4.6
10 reviews
5
7
4
0
3
1
2
0
1
2
Daniela Esquivel
April 8, 2026

Espectacular, los mejores bagels que me he comido, cada bocado una delicia y la atención del lugar increíble todos demasiado amables, hacen que este lugar sea una recomendación 100/10

Owner Response:

Muchas gracias Daniela

Mariana Sarkissian
April 7, 2026

Let me just start by saying: these bagels might have saved my final weeks of pregnancy. I’m currently 9 months pregnant, deep in the “cravings come out of nowhere and will not be ignored” phase. I happened to watch a behind-the-scenes interview showing how these bagels are made with the owner, and the SECOND that video ended… the craving hit. HARD. So naturally, I went straight online and to my absolute delight, saw they ship nationwide through Goldbelly. I ordered on a Sunday, and like some kind of carb-loaded miracle, they arrived within TWO days.
I got 5 French toast, 5 sesame, and 5 onion. The moment the box landed on my doorstep, I didn’t even hesitate. Opened it up, grabbed a French toast bagel, and popped it straight into the toaster.
And wow. Just… WOW.
From the very first bite, I was completely in love. The texture? Perfect. The flavor? Unreal. And that chew factor?? Exactly what a true bagel should be. Everything you want, nothing you don’t. Honestly, I can now go into labor happy knowing I’ve got a stash of these waiting for me when I get home with my baby. ???? Yes, it’s a bit of a splurge but 1000% worth it for the quality. These aren’t just bagels… they’re an experience.
Highly, HIGHLY recommend & cannot wait to visit the brick in mortar for a bagel sandwich on the future! Sharing with lots of love from Boston, MA ♥️

Owner Response:

Mariana, this might be our favorite review ever. First of all—congratulations!! Wishing you the smoothest delivery and all the best in these final weeks. The fact that our bagels were part of those very real 9-month cravings honestly means everything to us. We love that you saw the behind the scenes and immediately needed them—that’s exactly the kind of reaction we hope for! And the way you described that first French toast bagel moment… WOW. You get it. The texture, the chew, the flavor—that’s what we work so hard to perfect every single day. Also, knowing you’ve got a post-hospital bagel stash waiting for you?? That’s elite planning. Thank you so much for trusting us (especially during such an important time!) and for sharing the love all the way from Boston. We can’t wait to welcome you into the shop for that bagel sandwich in person.

Devildiver
April 6, 2026

Die Bagel hier sind wirklich köstlich, ich kann sie nur wärmstens empfehlen.

Owner Response:

Thank you for coming in! We’re thrilled you enjoyed and look forward to your return

Roy Melendez
April 5, 2026

Was really excited to try these bagels, they where ok, nothing outstanding. Service was great, everyone was kind and attentive.

Owner Response:

We appreciate your honest feedback and look forward to your return soon

SM
April 5, 2026

Service was rude, my sandwich was very plain, tables were sticky & not cleaned, and the music was loud. I heard good things about this place but honestly left feeling frustrated and couldn’t even finish my food.

It would be helpful if they had the bagel/bread choices on display for you to see before you order, and to have the line go past that window to see all the options. You can’t see the menu until you’re at the counter and the staff are aggressively asking you what you want. If you need more than 5 seconds to read the menu then they tell you to get out of the line.

Owner Response:

We thank you for letting us know and apologize for this. Kindly send us an email with more information of your visit to [email protected]

Jose Luis
April 5, 2026

Great place to get your NYC aunthentic bagels great service very customer focused and great environment to eat in its a little busy but worth every minute

Owner Response:

Thank you Jose! Our team looks forward to serving you again soon

Nirali Shah
April 4, 2026

We had many bagels. The build your own was amazing. These bagels are truly crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside. This was our third bagel stop on our New York trip and hands-down everyone liked it the most. The lattes were better than other places as well.

Owner Response:

Thank you so much Nirali, we’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our experience with having been to other shops. This means the world to us and we look forward to serving you again

Gela Kereselidze
April 4, 2026

Amazing place, best bagels ???? ever... locals famous place.. Great service fresh food and magic crispy bagels

Owner Response:

Thank you so much Gela! Our team looks forward to serving you again soon

Eric K
April 4, 2026

Ordered 4 bagels. 3 of them were wrong. Wildly overpriced, definitely a tourist trap. A far cry from the original in Queens. Sad

Owner Response:

Eric, we’re sorry to hear about this experience. Kindly email us at [email protected]

David William Torres Chulde
April 4, 2026

Awesome, tasty food!

Owner Response:

Thank you so much David!

Top restaurants


Frequently Asked Questions

Utopia Bagels specializes in authentic style, Popular for in New York

Yes, some time. But Arriving early may reduce the waiting period.

The venue accepts credit cards as a form of payment, making it convenient for customers to settle their bills easily.

Bagel shop